Marcello Medici reviews and gives votes to this year's entries. Marcello is an active Eurovision fan, member of OGAE Italy and also has his own blog filled with European music, check it out here. Marcello has an admirable habit of not following the national finals and listens to the songs only when all or most of them have been chosen so his judgement is based on that; hearing the songs all together for the first time. Here goes:
The votes based on hearing the songs on video, some of them studio versions and some of them live performances puts them in an uneven situation and my opinions might change once I hear them all in CD. What strikes me the most in the first hearing is the difference in quality of the songs in the first and the second semifinal. In the second one there are better songs that risk to be left out in favour to the weaker ones in the first semifinal. Switzerland gains points because sung in French, and Croatia is my favourite of all the ballads this year. I would like to see all the Scandinavian countries in the final again, as well as Slovakia and Bulgaria because they sing in their own language. Of the favourites Israel and Romania didn't impress me with the first hearing. Af for the Big4 there is a definite step back from last year in France and UK while Spain sounds like a song for children but Germany saves itself with Lena Meyer-Landrut, already a megastar of the moment in her homecountry. Hopefully she will do well also in Oslo 2010. Here are my separete votes:
*****
Albania, Switzerland****
Moldova, Bulgaria, Croatia, Denmark***
Iceland, Malta, Slovakia, Germany, Armenia, Georgia, Ireland, Sweden**
Belarus, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Finland, Latvia, FYR Macedonia, Portugal, Serbia, Azerbaijan, Israel, Romania, Turkey, France, Norway, UK*
Belgium, Estonia, Greece, Poland, Russia, Spain, Cyprus, Lithuania, Netherlands, Slovenia, UkraineAnd here's Marcello's Top-10:
10. Malta, 9. Sweden, 8. Georgia, 7. Armenia, 6. Bulgaria, 5. Moldova, 4. Croazia, 3. Denmark, 2. Albania and 1. Switzerland
Comments